Ford Muscle Cars Tech Forum banner

Building a Custom "eXhaust"

27K views 31 replies 16 participants last post by  dazecars  
#1 · (Edited by Moderator)
When it comes to working on your classic Ford there is always the choice to do something yourself or to farm the work out to a professional. As a beginner in this hobby there are many things you must farm out simply because you do not have the skills or tools to effectively do the job your self. The good news is that this hobby is cumulative and the more little project you can do the more experience you will have, allowing you to tackle bigger and bigger projects.

Some times you farm out the project, simply because you don’t THINK you can’t do it, but the reality is you probably can. A perfect example of this is the exhaust. A lot of people do 99% of the work on their car from mechanics to paint and everything in between and then take the car to a muffler shop to have the exhaust done. I think there is two reasons for this, first they don’t have a pipe bender, and the second reason is that they are worried about all the different directions the exhaust needs to go to get it to fit properly. I am here to tell you that any one with a good metal cutting chop saw and a welder can make their own exhaust. I made what I like to refer to, as an “eXhaust” for my Mustang and it was not that hard.
Image


Materials
It doesn’t take a lot of materials to make an exhaust. Obviously you need exhaust pipe, Mufflers, and either manifolds or headers to come off of the engine. There are also the optional pieces such as exhaust tips and exhaust balancers such as an “X” or “H” pipe. In some cases you may want to buy some pre-made elbows, or take a stick of pipe to a local exhaust shop and have some bends put into it so that you can cut out the bends you need and weld them in to place. Having the stick of pipe pre-bent is a nice option if you want mandrel bent exhaust however is not required as there is still another option that I like to refer to as cut and rotate method.

Cut and Rotate
The cut and rotate method is simple enough but does take a specific technique to get it to work correctly. The first thing I like to do is mark the pipe on opposite sides with a straight line. The lines are applied by putting two marks equally spaced apart on the end of the pipe and then using a piece of angle iron as a straight edge to extend the mark down the length of the pipe.
Image


Image


Image


This is not necessary on a single cut bend but as you will see is very important on multi cut pieces.
Once I have the pipe marked it is time to start cutting. The basis of the technique is to put the pipe in the chop saw with one of the lines positioned in such a way so that the pipe can easily be removed from the saw and then repositioned in the same orientation or the exact opposite orientation. To facilitate this I used a silver sharpie to make a mark on the back side of the chop saw guide to give me a place to line up with lines on the pipe.
Image


With the pipe in the saw it can then cut at an angle leaving you two angled pieces.
Image


Image


If you take one of those pieces and rotate it 180 degrees so that the opposite lines match up and the put the tubes together, the angled openings on the end of the pipe will also line up and can be welded together giving you a bend that is twice the angle of the original cut.
Image


The beauty of this type of technique is that you get a smooth transition as the tubing openings will line up perfectly. Keep in mind that with this technique the final angle of the bend results in the sum of the individual pieces. Example on ten-degree cut creates two pieces with a 10 degree angle on them, phase one of the pieces out 180 degrees, and welded them together and the result will be a bend of 20 degrees. In the same way two, eleven-degree cuts, resulting in four angles on three pieces (one wedges between two piece of angled pipe) will result in a 44-degree bend.

Multi-cut bends are where the lines become critically important. After the first cut the pipe will need to be removed from the saw and repositioned for the next cut. Each cut will need to be the opposite of the cut before it and to achieve this the pipe will need to be rotated 180 degrees from the direction was originally positioned in for the previous cut. The reason for this is so that the second cut can be the opposite direction of the first one with out having to change the saw cutting angle.

Even if you did change the saw cutting Angle the pipe would still need to be repositioned so it makes more sense to leave the saw angle alone and simply reposition the pipe. By having the lines you have a mark to go by to insure the cuts are truly opposite. You simply rotate the pipe so that the second line is in the same position relative to the saw as the first line was.
Image


Once you have the piece rotated you can make the second cut, and from there you can simply weld the pieces together resulting in a nice bend.
Image


With the cut and rotate technique you now have an option that will allow you to make all the bends necessary to build the exhaust and is fairly smooth flowing on the inside.
Image


Obviously this technique will not be as free flowing as a mandrel bent exhaust but for the average street machine it will function very well.

Choosing the correct exhaust pipe diameter
There is a common misconception in the automotive world that bigger is always better when it come exhaust pipe. I have herd people recommend that you run the biggest pipe that you can easily fit under your car. This can be bad advice. Yes the bigger the exhaust the more freely it will flow, however bigger also means slower and the slower the gasses exiting the exhaust are moving the less scavenge you will have in the combustion chamber which will result in less power.

On the flip side, to small of an exhaust will be restrictive at high RPMs robbing the engine of horsepower. As with most things relating to engines there is a balance to be had between low end torque and horsepower in contrast to overall torque horsepower. With this in mind engine RPMs under normal use will effect desired exhaust size with lower RPM engines needing smaller diameter pipe than higher RPM engines so as to maintain exhaust velocity.

A good rule of thumb is to use 2” to 2.25” dual exhaust for a 300 to 350 cubic inch engine (depending on desired RPM use) and then increase or decrees the exhaust size proportionally to the engine size. Keep in mind that exhaust pipe that has twice the diameter of any given size will flow four times the CFM. Example a 3” exhaust will flow twice the CFM as a 2” exhaust and for times the CFM as a 1.5” exhaust.

Parts I Chose
For my specific application I started with 2 headers, two collectors, one home made X pipe, two 24" glass packs and a 10' stick of 2.25" exhaust pipe. I chose all these components specifically because the engine in my Mustang has a fairly lopey cam and I wanted it to breath freely at higher RPMs.

Start at the engine and work back
Prior to redoing the exhaust on my car coming off my heads were an old rusted set of headers that had come in contact with the road enough times that the bottom tubes were at about half capacity, so when I decided to redo the exhaust I new I needed new headers. My Mustang has the first generation Uni-steer manual rack and pinion steering unit in it and one of the downfalls of this particular unit is only a few stiles of headers seams to clear the Uni-steer steering shaft. To make matters worse these headers are over $500.00 a set and I didn't want to pay that kind of money for headers.

I decided to get a quality set of headman 88300 which have ball type collectors and 1 & 5/8" tubes. They cost me about $160.00 for the set. When I installed them (with the Uni-steer steering shaft removed) the fit was fantastic they cleared the shock towers by at least 1/8" and more than that in most places. When I went to reinstall the steering shaft there was an obvious problem. The steering shaft had to pass directly through the middle of one of the header tubes. I was fairly sure I would have a problem like this when I ordered the headers so I had already decided I would cut the tube and relocate it to clear the shaft.

Header Modification
The first step in modifying the headers was to mark the tube where it needed to be cut. With the headers bolted in place I eyeballed were the shaft needed to pass, marked the tube and then remove the header from the car and cut out the section that was in the way. Let me tell you there is something kind of heart breaking about cutting in to a brand new set of headers, especially headers that seamed to be such a perfect fit. With the tube out I reinstalled the header and the rack and pinion steering linkage to make sure that I had removed enough of the tube.

The next step was to determine where to reroute the tube. On a unmodified classic Mustang the drivers side header is always going to be an extremely tight fit because there is a steering box to try and get around not to mention clutch linkage on any manual transmission car. Obviously since I had upgraded to a rack and pinion, the steering box was gone, and even though my car has a manual transmission the clutch actuation is hydraulic so I had removed both of the parts that typically cause drivers side header clearance issues. This meant that I had a huge open cavity to which I could route my pipe.

Once I new approximately where I wanted to put the pipe I began cutting up the section of tubing that I had removed from the header using the cut and rotate method and was able to adjust the direction of the tubes and tack a piece in to place. I then did a test fit of the header. It took several test fits and slight modifications, but I was able to modify the headers to flow around the shaft.

In this picture of the last test fit, You can see just how much I had to modify the tube. Like I said before the original tube location would have gone right through the middle of the steering shaft.
Image


Once I new I had the headers the way I wanted them I welded up all the seams from the modification.
Image


I used the same technique used on body panels of putting individual small welds about .5” apart all the way around the tube and then filling in the gaps one weld at a time. This was done to produce a clean weld that could easily be ground off and would not burn through the tube.
Image


After getting the header tube welded up I took an angle grinder to the welds and am very pleased with the result!!!
Image


As I was grinding I was worried about the thickness of the header tubing and did not want to weaken it so I was very Conservative with my grinding which is why it is not perfectly smooth.
Image


Fabbing Up the Main Pipes
With the headers in place I positioned the X pipe where I wanted it, just behind the transmission and blocked it up. Keep in mind when setting up an X pipe type exhaust that at some point you may need to pull the transmission. In my case I set the exhaust up so that it could easily be removed as one whole piece should I need access to the transmission.

With the X pipe n place I bolted the collectors to the headers and then began cutting up the 10' stick of pipe using the “cut and rotate method” so that I could tack weld the pieces together to attach the collectors to the X pipe. From there connecting the X pipe to the to the mufflers was a simple straight run toward the back and side of the car so that the exhaust could exit just in front of the back tire.

Straight Through
From the driver’s side collector through the passenger’s side glass pack and the passenger’s side collector through the driver’s side glass pack I have a true straight through flow, which is why I call this an eXhaust.
Image


After the mufflers I made two sharp 45-degree (cut and rotate) bends to achieve the correct angle for the exhaust to leave the car. I did this with one 22-degree cut rather than several lesser degree cuts because I figured I would not make that much of a difference especially considering the location so I went with what was easiest. From there I simply tacked on some stainless steel tips to the end of the pipe so that the exhaust exits in stile. With the entire system tacked together, I removed it from the car and welded it all up solid using the same one weld at a time technique that I had used on the headers.

The last step was to take the headers and the exhaust to the powder coater to get ceramic coated. This coating not only looks good, but also will protect my exhaust from rusting. The interesting thing about ceramic coat is that you can polish it by glass beading it or with steel whole. The headers had been glass beaded at the powder coater but the full exhaust had not.
Image


Image


I polished up the ends near the stainless tips with some steel whole, but decided it was more work than I wanted to do on a part that would rarely be seen.
Image


The final install of the system was was easy and it went in with no issues
Image


Sounds different
The original exhaust on my car was long tube headers going in to duel pipes with no crossover. The glass packs were at least 30 years old and so the car was very loud, had a lot of deep rumble, and a nice lopy sound at idle.
Image


The new eXhaust I built with its straight through design, new glass packs and an "X" pipe in the middle, was, As expected quieter, has a slightly higher rumble and is not as lopy at idle. I hate to see those things go, but I new the "X" pipe and new mufflers would do that. The car should get a little louder and the rumble a little lower as I put some miles on the car which will break in the mufflers. The up side is that the car now has that circle track roar when you step on it and that along with the HP increase from balancing the exhaust banks makes the new exhaust well worth it in spite of what I lost.


.
 

Attachments

#3 ·
Your non-curved bends are not suitable for the exhaust because they limit gas flow. I would advise anyone trying to make custom exhaust to use mandrel-bent 90° elbows, even for small angles like 10-15 degrees. Heating elbows are not entirely suitable because of their thick wall compared to exhaust tubing - typically 1.5 or 2 mm vs. 3.2mm
 
#4 ·
It seems like the non-curved bends are suitable as he has the car running and probably driving. I have done the same thing on a few cars and though it may not be the best possible exhaust to extract every last amount of horsepower, they work fine. This type of project is Hot Rodding at it's finest!!!
 
#12 ·
Whats with the big holes in the floors?
Thats my technique for bleeding the hydraulic clutch my self :) :) :) When I bought the car there was a lot of cancer in the floor pans
Image

At the time lack of experience and lack of a welder forced me to "fix" them with new replacement pans window sealant compound and pop rivets. (worked very well for many years when the car was my DD

Image


Obviously that was not the best long term fix for rusted out pans and I have sense gone back to cut out all the bad sheet metal and weld in new. Seriously though with the driver's side pan out, that was the easiest clutch bleeding I have ever done. :)


and the flow at the end is minimal, loss is probably not even able to be measured
I agree, had those bends needed to be in front of the mufflers or even further than 12" from the exit, I would have made them more gradual but given there location I think the difference is minimal to negligible.
 
#8 · (Edited)
That it works and is cheap may not be sufficient for everyone. Even the cheapest exhaust pipes from china have oval (crushed) bends, and there must be reason for it.

And another advice - DON'T powdercoat headers!!! P/C s just plastic and it will burn off at the temperatures immediately. Even no part of exhaust should be p/c. Only zinc or galvanic chrome or hi-temp paint.
 
#10 ·
And another advice - DON'T powdercoat headers!!! P/C s just plastic and it will burn off at the temperatures immediately. Even no part of exhaust should be p/c. Only zinc or galvanic chrome or hi-temp paint.

Powder coating and ceramic coating are two different things. There applied the same, but cereamic coat is baked at a much hotter temp. Ceramic coat is harder as you can polish it with steel whole (can't do that with powder) Ceramic coating is designed for high temp applications such as headers. Even the header companies sell headers that are ceramic coated from the factory and come with a lifetime warranty on the FINISH.
 
#9 ·
#11 ·
I have written A LOT of car related DIY articles both here and on my own web page. There will always be those that disagree with my approach, or something I have said, or even the very idea of what I am doing. Not a problem, I am a mature adult and can take criticism, and arguments . When it comes to my work being attacked, I normally let it go. I have better things to do with my time than argue with those that disagree with me. In this particular case however the arguments are piling up and so I have a response.
I am by no means the last word in all things automotive. My area of "expertise" is suspension but even then I use the term lightly as I have much to learn. This is only the second exhaust I have built and undoubtedly have things I could do to make the next one better. With all that said I normally love constructive criticism, that is how I grow and learn, get different perspectives and more ideas than the ones I thought of. Normally good constructive criticism is a valuable tool to grow. What I can not understand is why this article is being attacked with the cry of "mandrel bent!!!" I am not claiming that my exhaust would be a better performing unit than a mandrel bent exhaust. in fact I say quite the opposite in the article:
"Obviously this technique will not be as free flowing as a mandrel bent exhaust but for the average street machine it will function very well."
I could understand it if I had said "why use mandrel bent when cutting and welding together is just as good" I said nothing of the sort. I understand that my sharp 45 degree bend, after the mufflers, offends, but I did not once recomend in the article that others do that. in fact in contrast I showed a technique that makes the same 45 with a much smoother transition.
The argument was made against the cut and rotate technique that no auto manufactures do it.
"Even the cheapest exhaust pipes from china have oval (crushed) bends, and there must be reason for it. "
Why would they cut and weld?? they have pipe benders. There is a lot of welding involved when you make an elbow this way and welding = time and time=$$$ in a major manufacturing situation. Why would a major manufacture spend 20 minutes making an elbow when they have a $10,00.00 machine that can make it for them in 60 seconds or less?? I am not trying to change the automotive industry, I am trying to give a guy working alone on his car in his garage another option.
ujt389, your comments make it sound like I went to the wrecking yard, bought a couple of old exhaust systems and cobbled them together with pipe clamps.
"There is a saying do it once and do it right. If I looked under a car and saw an exhaust like that it would make me wonder where else the owner has "saved money"."
Honestly does this look like an exhaust that has been slapped together with no concern of quality???
Image

When I was writing my X pipe and exhaust articles, I had no idea that that exhaust was such a taboo topic with only one correct answer "mandrel bent" For those who read this information and find something in it they can use, FANTASTIC. For those that read it and choose to go with a mandrel bent exhaust installed by them selves or a professional, FANTASTIC.
I hope that if those of you that have chosen to give criticism in such a way that it is beyond the point of being constructive, are treated far better should you ever put the time and effort in to a tech exchange article of your own. I know that I personally would be constructive.
 
#15 ·
A "good" exhauste system will cost over $300. Thats just headers back including all pipes, brackets, mufflers and crossovers. If you inlclude the cost of headers into this, your looking at almost $1000 for a full exhauste system.

The $300 number is very acurate as I have had a full system doen up for my Ranchero.

I for one do not have that kind of money, to throw around at will. No, credit cards are not the answer.

I looked at this atricle as an intresting way to building a better quality home crafted temporary exhauste system. One which will not promptly fall apart.

If the only issue with this system is the 45 degree angle on the tips, than make more cuts and decrease the angle. Or go pay to have a full system installed.
 
#18 ·
Does not matter if you end up with such exhaust for $300 or $10, you are ruining your ford. If you don't have money at least for mandrel bends, piping, and regular muffler (e.g. $30 summit, similar to flowmaster), spend time painting your existing exhaust, maybe patch the rusted parts, or grab some at junk yard, they will charge you near scrape metal price.
 
#22 ·
Hey Daze,
Like F15Falcon said, "This type of project is Hot Rodding at it's finest!!!" I couldn't agree more. Awesome job man! I just did exhaust on my ride yesterday and used a pre-bent setup from Mustangs Unlimited. It took me the whole day just to install pipes and get them lined up half decent, so I can appreciate what you've done here. Keep up the great work!
DJ
 
#27 · (Edited)
20 bucks don´t sound "helluva lot" to me either.
Use the bends. If you think corners like this is good enough for you, why bother?

Don´t get me wrong, it´s a nice write up, pics and all, but talk about cutting corners...

... Disagree also about size, it does matter. Why do you wan´t to add restriction to exhaust? Fast flowing always eats more energy than slow.
Any restriction on the exhaust never makes more power, horsepower or torque.

When we see pipes manufacturing like that in industry, we call them "Russian curves" ;)
 
#29 ·
20 bucks don´t sound "helluva lot" to me either.
Use the bends. If you think corners like this is good enough for you, why bother?
Thanks to everyone for their constructive thoughts, I really do appreciate it. There have been several who have said basically "for $20.00 why not mandrel" And I can see how that could be a valid argument. But lets look at it this way. It not just about $$ its about time and opportunity and doing it yourself.

I live in a small town in MT so shipping is usually a minimum of 7 days. there is no one locally who does or sells mandrel bends so I must special order. Lets say I order a bend and get everything I need so that in a week I can build my exhaust. Then on the day I set aside to make the exhaust, I make a mistake. I incorrectly cut up the bend. (keep in mind that with out a band saw, cleanly cutting a preebent elbow is easier said than done) Then what do I do?? I weight another 7 days to get another elbow. An immediate response to that would be order two elbows to begin with, there again extra $$.

For the real slight bends between the collectors and the X (those were 5 degree cuts) I don't think there will be that much difference in flow between the way I did it rather than using a sliver of a preebent elbow.

When you look at it that way my choice was to put together a quality exhaust with the time and materials I had or weight a week, spend more $$ to use something that might only minimally improve performance and hope I am perfect when fabbing it up so that I don't have to weight another week.

The only other bends in my exhaust are the 45s at the tail pipes, and I have already conceded that I should have done those differently. If I had made that a 3 angle or 4 angle bend the flow would have been fairly smooth. Not as good as mandrel bent but not far off.

Further more the aftermarket has convinced us to spend money rather than doing things our selves and I am a firm believer and advocate in DIY. I haver herd people say "why port and polish a good set of stock Ford heads like E7s when you can buy aftermarket aluminum heads" This statement horrifies me, yes a set of aftermarket aluminum heads will far out perform a set of E7s that have been correctly ported and polished and port and polish is A LOT of work. But for the enthusiast that has way more time than money the port and polish makes sense, not to mention the feeling of accomplishment in knowing that they improved the HP of there car simply by putting in the time and effort.

The same is true of my exhaust, I built it my self, no aftermarket support other than the mufflers and headers, and even the headers have been reworked. If it were an issue of $$ what is the magic dollar amount?? when does the performance increase become cost prohibitive?? I am quite positive that the difference in HP between my exhaust and and one made of mandrel bent elbows will only be a few horses maybe 1%. If I want to have an exhaust that would allow for every last bit of horse power I should have had a professional build one fore me that was mandrel bent and had as few joints as possible.


Lastly and this is a BIG ONE when you cut a bent tube some where along the radios the opening will not be perfectly round unless you cut it at exactly the perfect angle. that means that when you weld it up it will not exactly match the straight pipe you are welding it to and will create a turbulence point worse than the joints I am making because in my case the two pieces line up perfectly as they were cut from each other. Yes I probably have more cuts, not many more. If you are going to build an exhaust in sections by welding it together, mandrel bent or not there will be a lot of turbulence. So with that said if you want the true benefit of mandrel bent you need to have a professional do it so it is a 1 or 2 piece exhaust.

Every one is assuming that my technique is worse than or equal to a crimp bend found on most OEM exhausts, but this has never been testes so no one really knows. On the flip side everyone that keeps saying "mandrel bent" speaks of it as though an exhaust that is put together with many sections of mandrel bends, is some how just as good as one that has been made from only one ore two sections with all the bends bent directly in to that single pipe, and that could not be further from the truth.

The reality is none of us really know exactly how an exhaust that is made of many sections, my technique or mandrel is really going to perform and all we can do is speculate. My OPINION is that a well built cut and rotate exhaust will function nearly as well as a welded together exhaust that utilizes mandrel bends cut in to sections and welded in to place.

Nice job building a 'functional' exhaust.
But, calling it 'high performance' is kind of misleading.
Once again thanks for commenting constructively. stock exhaust manifolds going to a 2" Y pipe is a "functional exhaust". The moment you start changing things it becomes a performance exhaust. Headers going to a stock Y pipe will be performance. Headers going to dual exhaust still will be higher performance. Headers, dual exhaust, some sort of crossover, larger diameter than stock pipes, ceramic coating to help hold in the heat, are all things that make for a "high performance exhaust". Yes mandrel bends and even bigger pipes would have made for an even higher performance exhaust, but so would have equal tube length headers and no mufflers. Not having these things does not put my exhaust in the same category a stock Y pipe or even Headers going to a stock dual exhaust. The term "highEST performance" would be misleading but not "high performance" IMHO :) :) :) :)
 
#28 ·
Nice job of writing it up, and the exhaust will work 'just fine'....

But, with just a -little- extra money, the exhaust could be a true performance enhancer.
2.5" to 3.0" pipe and mandrel bends go a LONG way in making power.

2-1/4" pipe and crush/wrinkled/angled bends will work just fine on a 'ratrod' or something, but won't do anything for power production.

Do the SAME THING you did with 3" and mandrel bends, and you've got a winner.

Summit even sells kits with a mandrel bent X-pipe, FOUR 45Âş mandrel bends AND clamps for $99. I bought one a long time ago, and just used the 45Âş bends... after giving away the X section. These kits are available in different sizes as well. Mine was 3".

Nice job building a 'functional' exhaust.
But, calling it 'high performance' is kind of misleading.
It will be loud and 'cackly', especially with the small pipe and glasspacks, but it's not really built to be unrestrictive when it comes to making very much horsepower.

Good Luck